How I Ruined My Credit Score: 3 Debt Truths You Need To Know

My story of how I ruined my debt score

“You can’t be doing this.”

Those words came from the mouth of my financial advisor as we discussed my credit options. On his side of the desk, a monitor displaying my FICO score. On my side, feelings of sheepishness, frustration, and more than a little bewilderment. He was referring to my longstanding habit of paying just the minimum on my credit card bill – one I always paid dutifully on time, and, unbeknownst to me, was ripping my credit score to shreds.

I had been carrying close to my max limit for several years at that point – a balance I had wracked up in bygone days of early 20’s hijinks. Now that I was considerably more responsible (and making considerably more money), I wasn’t too worried. The debt amount in question was only a few thousand dollars – and after all, I made enough to pay it off eventually, right?

That would be a big, fat, NO. As I was about to learn, carrying an almost-maxed balance is one of the cardinal sins of credit – it’s a sign to lenders that you aren’t responsible with debt repayment. As my advisor put it, “If you had waited any longer to intervene, chances are in a few months, you wouldn’t qualify for any kind of credit at all.” Gulp. A mortgage for the home my partner and I have been saving for? Forget about it.

And so, I took action – I applied for a consolidation loan at a lower interest rate than my card, paid off the balance and closed the sucker. Now, I’m on the virtuous path of rebuilding my credit. And I’m lucky – I caught it in time, and didn’t have to leverage any assets, like my home or car, against the debt. But here’s what I wish I had known, far, far sooner.

Truth 1: Don’t Hide From Your Credit Score

While my score took a nosedive, I was oblivious – and even financially smug. I was paying my bills on time and starting to save for retirement and homeownership. However, it had been a while since I had lifted the cover on my credit score – if only I had earlier.

Your credit score consists of three digits based on your personal credit history – it’s created the first time you borrow money. The number ranges from 300 – 900, with roughly 600 being the cutoff point for most lenders. Banks and businesses use it to determine the level of risk you pose as a borrower. Here’s what it’s based on, according to the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada:

  • When you opened your debt account
  • The amount you owe on your debt (and yes, this includes revolving balances like credit card debt!)
  • Whether you make your payments on time
  • Whether you’ve ever gone over your credit limit

Your reliability with everyday bills, like TV, cable and phone are also reported to your credit bureau and impact your score. So are big commitments, like payments made on a mortgage. Generally you’ll need a score of at least 720 to qualify for a mortgage – any lower and you’ll be knocking on the door of a lender specializing in high risk buyers, for a higher than desired rate.

Checking your credit score gets a bad rap because the act of pulling the information in itself can ding it. But trust me – if any of the above behaviours sound like you, it’s high time for a check in.

Truth 2: Getting Into Debt Is Easy

The most dangerous thing about debt is how innocuously it can become a presence in your life. I had wracked up my card on silly incidentals – clothes shopping, travel plans, dinners out. I had also used it for emergencies – a cross-country flight home after being laid off three provinces away. Probably the biggest, and most stupid, abuse was walking into the Coach store and charging another $500 to my balance. With interest, that purse still costs me money every day. The irony is not lost on me.

According to BDO Canada, a national tax and financial advisory service, simple money mismanagement is enough to fall into a debt hole. Says Andre Bolduc, trustee in Bankruptcy and senior vice–president at BDO, “Tracking spending against income needs to become a habit for Canadians in order to avoid accumulating high levels of debt.”

According to Bolduc, these are the fastest ways to fall into debt:

  • Failing to track spending accurately, right down to the last “nickel”, and relying on credit to cover the shortfalls

  • Considering your tax refund as a windfall rather than reducing the deduction at source, and using the extra cash to pay down debt

  • Not having an emergency fund and using credit to cover costs

  • Forgetting to account for the ‘once a year’ bills such as home insurance, and putting the payment on a credit card

  • Indulging yourself or others with items you cannot afford to be buying

Guilty across the board.

Truth 3: Fixing Debt Takes Dedication

I went the consolidation route for the interest break it provides – I’ll be paying less than half of what my credit card would charge. It also gave me the opportunity to close the card. While I still use a credit card as part of my score building strategy – a low interest one designed for culprits like me – I have to be fastidious with paying it off immediately. If that approach is too disciplined, or if your credit score is too far gone, here are a few other steps you can take, according to BDO:

  • Get a second job and put the income towards the debt

  • Stop using your credit cards and make regular monthly payments towards the balance

  • Try the snowball effect – pay down the debt with the highest interest first, then move to the next highest and so on OR if you need quicker gratification, work the opposite way just recognize the additional money you will pay on the higher interest loan(s)

  • Repaying the debt on your own by creating a plan and sticking to it

  • Contacting your lenders to work out an affordable repayment schedule

  • Seeking the advice of a qualified professional to guide you through bankruptcy, consumer proposal, etc.

  • Borrowing from family at a reduced interest rate. However, use this “life line” with caution by setting up a mutually agreeable repayment schedule that preserves the relationship.

BDO adds that consolidation is a good option if the rate is lower than the average of all your loans, and you earn enough, or hold enough equity, to cover the total debt. Bankruptcy is an option for extreme cases – if you’ve exhausted all borrowing opportunities from friends and family, taken on more employment, sold your assets, or cannot acquire a loan.

A recommendation from RateSupermarket

Related Topics

Credit Card Debt / Debt Repayment / Personal Finance / Your Credit Score

6 thoughts on “How I Ruined My Credit Score: 3 Debt Truths You Need To Know

  1. Hi Penelope I enjoy many articles that you write and share many of them on my Facebook. This article while well written and mostly accurate, incorrectly states
    “Generally you’ll need a score of at least 720 to qualify for a mortgage – any lower and you’ll be knocking on the door of a lender specializing in high risk buyers, for a higher than desired rate.”
    That is incorrect and IMO damages the great job that Mortgage Brokers do. With a score of 720 ANY lender would drool to have you, but mortgage approvals with the best broker rates are regularly approved with beacons as low as 620, and 650 being a very healthy score. 680 is where the doors open for higher debt servicing, allowing buyers to stretch their dollars a little farther.
    The ONLY time buyers would be taken to high risk lenders is if they have completely wrecked credit, and even then, they have to have something to offer, usually huge down payments 35% + or, on refinance, huge equity in the property.
    Credit score is very important, but only one part of the scenario, many other factors go into putting a deal together for a mortgage.
    Regards, Deborah

    • Hi Deborah,
      Thanks for the kind words and the clarification. You’re correct – the above line about credit scores should reflect that 720 is the cutoff for a really, really competitive rate, rather than being turned away for lower debt options.

      Thanks for reading, and for sharing your knowledge!

  2. The amount of unutilized credit lines is also an important factor in credit ratings. When your card is maxed out there is no unused credit available.

  3. Sorry to hear about your experience. Unfortunately, I don’t think you’re an isolated case of your generation. Your story of how your debt got out of hand is a perfect example of how I witness young adults spend money they don’t have on luxury items they cannot afford without worrying about the fact that it has to be paid back eventually. They need to start teaching basic money management in schools again like they did when I went to school.

    • Hi Saddened,
      In retrospect of my own experience, I absolutely agree with you – I think the largest disconnect for many young people is understanding (and having the discipline) to always live within their means. The lack of knowledge shared early on, combined with the perception that carrying large amounts of debt is normal in our society, creates a perfect storm for debt creation.

  4. Checking your own credit score does not, in fact, ding it.
    Also, an alternative approach to debt reduction is neither what you call the “snowball” (paying off the highest interest rate debt first) or “its opposite” (paying off the lowest interest rate first?) – instead, it’s paying off the smallest *balance* first, then rolling that payment into paying off the next lowest balance, then rolling those two payments into the next debt, and so on … that is a *true* snowball.

Leave a Reply