5 Ways to Turn Leftover Halloween Candy into Christmas Treats

Halloween Baking

The spooky season of ghouls and ghosts may be over for 2014 – but there are still plenty of treats in store, as Canada ramps up for the holiday season. Still have a ton of Halloween candy on hand? Put it to good use (and save on baking supplies) with these no-fail (and no-fear) holiday recipes. They’re so deliciously awesome, you may even find yourself hiding candy from trick or treaters…

Tip: Take advantage of cheap candy day (November 1st): If you know that there is no such thing as leftover candy in your house but you know you want to stock up for holiday baking, be sure to hit the stores on November 1st for 80% off your favorite candies.

#1. Stained Glass Ornament Cookies

Stained Glass final

If you’re got extra hard candies on hand, be sure to keep them around to make these delicious cookies that double as holiday decorations. I’ve even given out these tasty delights as gifts in the past. I’ve done the stained glass using jolly ranchers and life savers but any hard candy will do.

Get the recipe>

#2. Gingerbread Houses

Gingerbread Final

Making gingerbread houses is one of my favourite holiday traditions. When it comes to decorating – any candy will do. Here’s a handy list of what candy you can use for decorating your house, however, feel free to let your creativity guide you.

Get the recipe>

#3. Tootsie Roll Fudge

Tootsie Roll Final

This fudge recipe is not only delicious, but fast and easy to make. Inspired by a woman who’s husband came home with 50 pounds of tootsie rolls he bought on discount.

Get the recipe>

#4. Peanut Butter S’mores Bars {no bake!}

Smores Final

This no-bake recipe for s’mores bars is not only a breeze to put together – you don’t even need to bake it. I’ve used this same base and substituted different chopped up candy bars for the mini peanut butter cups. I’ve even used a mishmash of different mini chocolate bars chopped together.

This recipe is perfect to have on hand if you’ve got guests coming over and you need to whip up something in a pinch (such is the holidays).

Get the recipe>

#5. No Fuss Chocolate Bar Chocolate Brownies

Candybar Brownies Frame

This is my go-to brownie recipe during the holidays. The candy in the middle will ooze into the rest of your brownies. I like using a nut based chocolate bar like O’Henry or Snickers.


1 Box of Chocolate Cake Mix (I use devil’s foodcake)

3/4 cup melted butter

2/3 cup sweetened condensed milk

1 cup of chopped chocolate treats


1)      In a large bowl combine your cake mix, melted butter, and condensed milk. Using a wooden spoon stir together until smooth.

2)      Lightly greese a 13×9 inch pan, and preheat the oven to 350F.

3)      Pour half of the cake mixture into the pan and smooth out with a spatula.

4)      Bake for 10 minutes and remove from oven.

5)      Sprinkle the chopped chocolate treats on top evenly.

6)      Take the remaining banner and pour on top of the treats.

7)      Pop the mixture into the oven for 25 minutes.

8)      Let cool for 10 minutes before slicing to allow them to set.

Do you have any favourite frugal holiday baking tips? Share them in a comment, or visit us on Facebook and Twitter!


Related Topics

Lifestyle / Lifestyle News / Personal Finance / Personal Finance News / Your Budget

Leave a Reply